Are Center Cities the
Engines of Growth for
their Suburbs?
A Re-Evaluation Of The Economic Relationship Using Evidence From Virginia’s
Metropolitan Areas
By Xiaobing Shuai
Xiaobing Shuai is a senior economist
with Chmura Economics &
Analytics in Richmond, VA. His
interest rate forecasts are published
in the “Blue Chip Financial
Forecasts” and his real estate forecasts
are published in the
“Housing Market Report.” He is a
native of China, and graduated
from Fudan University in Shanghai. His M.A. in agricultural
economics and Ph.D. in economics are from the
University of Wisconsin-Madison. His thesis, “Foreign
Direct Investment in Developing Countries: Motives,
Structures, and Impacts” was awarded the Henry Taylor
Doctoral Dissertation Award.
For decades, center cities of metropolitan areas were
regarded as the growth engines of their suburbs.
However, this paradigm has been shifting in the past
twenty years in Virginia, where suburbs have been growing
faster than center cities. Consequently, there is a
need in economic development communities to re-evaluate
the economic relationship between center cities and
their suburbs. This paper develops a statistical test to
determine the cause-effect ties between these two
economies and concludes that Virginia’s cities are no
longer the growth engines of their suburbs. The opposite is almost true: suburbs are on the verge of becoming the
leaders for city economic growth. To further the understanding
of what drives the city/suburban economy, the
study also tests the cause-effect relationship between population
growth and employment growth and finds that
population growth still exerts a strong influence on
employment growth. This knowledge can be useful in
designing policies to promote the economic growth of
both cities and suburbs.
This paper won a NABE Award for an outstanding paper contributed by a NABE member. Standard & Poor’s sponsored the award. The paper was
presented at the NABE Annual Meeting on September 26, 2005.